Above: Aigul Akhmetshina
~ Author: Oberon
Saturday January 27th, 2024 matinee - Feeling no need to see a 6-ton tractor trailer on the stage of the Metropolitan Opera House, I took a score desk for today's matinee of the Met's new production of CARMEN. I wasn't feeling my best this morning as I prepared to leave for Lincoln Center, and even considered staying home. But once the house lights dimmed, my spirits perked up, CARMEN is an opera I had not heard for a very long time, and the music seemed truly fresh to me today.
The main draw of the day was Aigul Akhmetshina, the gorgeous Russian mezzo-soprano, in the title-role. I fell under she spell when she sang Maddalena in Verdi's RIGOLETTO here last season, which I saw three times.
Maestro Daniele Rustioni got the opera off to a fast start, setting a brisk tempo with the start of the prelude. Unlike some of the other conductors the Met favors these days, Rustioni is not a volume freak; the voices were - for the most part - clearly audible throughout the opera, and his tempi always felt right. I especially like his accelerations as each repeat of the theme of the Act II Danse Bohème sped up: exhilarating! The preludes to the four acts were beautifully played, particularly the touching music that introduces Act III. All the choral work was super as well, notably the lovely smoking chorus in Act I.
The first solo voice we hear is that of Morales, sung very impressively today Benjamin Taylor; it's a Met-sized voice of handsome timbre. Equally striking was the singing of Wei Wu as Zuniga. Both these gentlemen deserve more opportunities at The Met.
Carmen's friends - Frasquita (Sydney Mancasola), Mercedes (Briana Hunter), Dancairo (Michael Adams), and Remendado (Frederick Ballentine) - joined Ms. Akhmetshina for the quintet in Act II, excelling at the quick repartee. Ms. Mancasola popped off some bright top notes at the end of the Toreador Song and at "La Liberté!" to end the third act.
Micaela is the first principal character to appear, in the person of Angel Blue. This role suits Ms. Blue far better than Violetta did last season. She sounded warm and lyrical in the duet with Don José, etching in some appealing piano effects. And her aria in Act III - with its finely-played horn introduction - was a vocal highlight of the afternoon; Ms. Blue's rich voice could be tapered smoothly to a sweet softness, making for a spine-tingling finish. Her final plea, with its stunning drop at "Ah, José!", was beautifully handled.
Maestro Rustioni provided a whiplash start to the famous Toreador Song; Kyle Ketelsen sang the familiar tune engagingly, and he was excellent in his 'fight' duet with José in Act III. Later - before the bullfight commences - he and Ms. Akhmetshina shared a lyrical moment.
Above: Piotr Beczala
Piotr Beczała's bio says he is 57 years old, but he certainly doesn't sound it...nor look it, when I chatted him up at the stage door after the performance: he's a very handsome guy, with an easy-going charm. His singing today as was most impressive, covering a wide dynamic range, from passionate, house-filling outpourings to ravishingly heady tones. He and Angel Blue blended voices perfectly in their Act I duet, trading phrases persuasively, and finishing off with Piotr's amazingly hush-toned "Souvenirs du pays..."
Chez Lillas Pasta, after Carmen upbraids José for abandoning her when the trumpets summon him back to the barracks, Mr. Beczala gave us his poetic Flower Song, so ardently voiced...and with a fascinating pianissimo climax to the final phrase.
When the music turns darker and the menacing edge of jealousy overtakes Don José, Mr, Beczala unleashed the power of his voice to thrilling effect. The character's descent into madness was set forth in vocal terms, with a manic desperation in his singing of the final, deadly encounter with Carmen.
Aigul Akmenshina established herself as one of the finest Carmens imaginable. Introducing herself with a sultry Habanera - the second verse sung with enticing subtlety - the comely mezzo displayed a warm, dusky timbre with a plushy low range and smooth forays to the top. Aigul's Seguidilla put both the tenor and the audience under her spell with her creamy, gorgeous voice, topping it off with sustained final note.
Her singing of the the Chanson Bohème in the tavern scene veered from subtle to triumphant, but the fact that her later castanet song was not working on José as she'd expected unleashes her temper. After listening patiently to José's love plea, Carmen returns to enticement. Zuniga's arrival causes José to capitulate, and he joins the smugglers. My feeling here is that Carmen already hates him.
At the smugglers' den, Aigul's reading of the tarot cards was sung with doom-ladened low notes and a sense that time was running out for her. Her final meeting with Mr. Beczala's José was fiery, their exchanges quickly descending to threats and taunts. In this production, José kills Carmen with a baseball bat, which I am glad I could not see; the audience gasped.
Ms. Akhmetshina's is a welcome voice and presence on the Met stage, and I will always look forward to her performances; I also hope to one day hear her in Chausson's Poème de l'amour et de la mer, for which I think she has the perfect voice.
The few times I glimpsed the the stage setting today, it looked cheap and junky. A real eyesore.
After the performance, I went to the stage door where I met Aigul and Piotr; they are such kind and lovely people.
~ Oberon