Above: at The Old Met, final scene of FAUST
In November, 1965, I saw my last performances at the Old Met. This was my first "long weekend" at the opera; such weekends became my routine over the next 30 years. In the late Summer of 1966, I would make first solo trip to New York City to join the box office line for the opening performances at the New Met, where I was to see hundreds of performances in the ensuing seasons. That saga started here, and continues to this day.
But in the Autumn of 1965, the Old Met was still The Met. For me, it was thrilling to see four performances in three days, and I wished that there were weekday matinees that I could have gone to: I wanted opera, all day, all the time. It hadn't yet occurred to me that the productions had to be rehearsed.
My long weekend opened with the first Verdi opera I ever saw at The Met:
This was a thrilling experience, and I thought parts of the performance compared favourably with the old Milanov-Bjoerling RCA recording that I'd learned TROVATORE from.
Gabriella Tucci (above) was, at that time, my favorite soprano; having heard her on many Texaco broadcasts - as Butterfly, Aida, Violetta, Desdemona, Alice Ford, and the FORZA Leonora - she set a standard for the way I thought these roles should (or could) be sung.
Tucci's legato, and her persuasive way of spinning out the vocal line, made every phrase of her Leonora enjoyable. In her great fourth act aria, "D'amor sull'ali rosee", Tucci reached an exalted interpretive level; she followed this with a dramatic rendering of the "Miserere". In those years, the cabaletta "Tu vedrai che amor" was never sung - in fact, I never even knew it existed until I heard Martina Arroyo sing it on a Met broadcast in the 1970s. Ms. Tucci capped her lovely performance with a magnificent, sustained pianissimo on her final "addio..." before the opera rushed to its close.
Gabriella Tucci - D'amor sull'all rosee ~ TROVATORE
Bruno Prevedi (above) was a handsome man with a sturdy spinto sound. He sang 65 performances with the Met, in New York and on tour, over three-year span. He was Anna Moffo's Alfredo in the Cecil Beaton TRAVIATA, and he was Don Carlo in Claudio Abbado's Met debut performance. Although his sound was not particularly distinctive, I enjoyed everything I heard him sing during those years. When his Met career ended, Prevedi continued to sing extensively in Europe and South America until 1982, he passed away in 1988, aged 60.
In this performance as Manrico, his voice was house-filling, warm, and clear; he was well-applauded without raising the audience's wild enthusiasm the way Corelli, Bergonzi, and Tucker did.
Bruno Prevedi - MACBETH ~ O figli o figli miei!
Rita Gorr (above) was a thrilling Azucena; her voice sounded huge in the House, and she was the dominating force of the evening. Gorr's Met career, however, was not extensive; over a 4-year span, she sang 40 performances with the Company. During the first season at the New Met, she sang four performances as Amneris, and was thereafter never heard there again.
I lost track of her after that, but apparently vocal problems had cropped up. Her career continued in Europe, though in smaller roles. I therefore consider myself fortunate to have heard her in peak form in this TROVATORE.
Rita Gorr - Samson et Dalila ~ Printemps qui commence
Robert Merrill (above) was already a great favorite of mine from his many broadcasts and recordings. I was excited to be hearing him in the House, where he was a huge audience favorite, winning entrance applause and lots of bravos at his curtain calls.
Robert Merrill - TROVATORE ~ Il balen del suo sorriso
Bonaldo Giaiotti (above) was an excellent Ferrando. He had already established himself as my primo basso and, as the years went by, I never had much cause to think of him as anything else. It's still the bass sound I most love to hear.
Bonaldo Giaiotti - Come dal ciel precipita ~ MACBETH
Georges Prêtre conducted this TROVATORE, wherein I sometimes thought he pushed the orchestra for volume at the expense of the singers. Two days later, he conducted FAUST, and it seemed perfect.
[Note: Joann Grillo replaced Rosalind Elias as Suzuki.]
This performance of BUTTERFLY marked Licia Albanese's last appearance in this role which was so closely associated with her. It was, in fact, her penultimate performance with the Company; in January 1966 she sang MANON LESCAUT as her farewell to the Met stage, and in July, she appeared with the Company as Mimi in a concert performance of LA BOHEME at the Newport Festival.
Of this last of the diva's many Butterflies, I wrote: "The great Albanese in her greatest role...in fine voice, with good, strong top notes, she was especially good both in her singing and acting in Act II. A great artist, a famous portrayal! Met her, and got her autograph."
Licia Albanese - Ancora un passo or via ~ MADAMA BUTTERFLY
At this point in time, Barry Morell was the tenor I had most frequently encountered in live performance: he had sung the Duke of Mantua, Alfredo Germont, and Massenet's des Grieux at Cincinnati Summer Opera. Morell was a generous singer, with an easy Italianate style.
Barry Morell - Addio fiorito asil - MADAMA BUTTERFLY
Joann Grillo (above), taking over from Rosalind Elias (who I had really been looking forward to hearing), sang well as Suzuki, and proved an attentive maid when she saw that the hem of Albanese's costume had caught on a stage-floor nail: Ms. Grillo quickly moved to release it.
John Robert Dunlap sang only two roles at The Met: Sharpless in BUTTERFLY and Jim Larkens in FANCIULLA DEL WEST. His final performance, as Larkens, was on April 11th, 1966: a student matinee which was the unannounced first-ever performance at the New Met at Lincoln Center. In what was described as a "sound test", busloads of students were the first people to experience an opera in the new theatre. Mr. Dunlap seems to have faded from memory soon after this performance, even though he was Renata Scotto's Sharpless at her Met debut.
The Saturday matinee of ELISIR D'AMORE brought together the much-admired tenor Nicolai Gedda and the lovely young Italian soprano Mirella Freni, who had only recently made her Met debut as Mimi and who went on to become a beloved star with the Company.
Nicolai Gedda - Elisir d'amore ~ Una furtiva lagrima
Mr. Gedda was immensely popular, and during the opera's single intermission the people near me were excited by the prospect of hearing his "Una furtiva lagrima" in Act II. Sure enough, it was superb.
Mirella Freni - Elisir d'amore ~ Prendi per me sei libero
Ms. Freni was a lyric rather than a coloratura Adina, and the wonderful freshness of her sound - as well as her graceful presence - charmed the audience.
Mario Sereni (above), with a voice I always loved to hear, was the swaggering Belcore. Once the Company moved to Lincoln Center, I saw him frequently, admiring him especially as Carlo Gerard in ANDREA CHENIER, Marcello in BOHEME, and as Tonio in PAGLIACCI.
Mario Sereni - Come Paride vezzoso ~ ELISIR D'AMORE
And the inimitable Fernando Corena (above), king of patter, was Dulcamara. This was one of the leading roles Corena sang, but for me he came to be most dearly remembered as the Sacristan in TOSCA over the ensuing years.
Fernando Corena - La vendetta ~ NOZZE DI FIGARO
Joy Clements (above, as Adele in FLEDERMAUS) made a sparkling impression as Giannetta; in the coming years, I saw her many times both at The Met and at New York City Opera where she had the distinction of singing both Mozart's Susanna (one of the best I ever encountered) and Carlisle Floyd's Susannah. In 1969, Joy Clements sang a fine Violetta as a guest artist at Syracuse, New York; at that time, I thought of her as a soubrette, and so I was very pleased with the deeper impression she made in TRAVIATA. She later sent me the above photo.
The ELISIR was conducted by the handsome, ill-fated Thomas Schippers (above). The matinee-idol maestro had made his Met debut in 1955, at the age of 25. He conducted nearly 350 performances at The Met (The Old and The New) and on tour, before being felled by lung cancer in 1977 at the age of 47.
Although I was still rather new to opera-going, I was already realizing that I much preferred tragic operas to comic ones. Over the ensuing years, I would gradually discard comedies from my 'repertoire'; but ELISIR can still lure me in, if there's a good cast
I can't remember why I did not go to the stage door after the ELISIR; perhaps I met my parents for supper before heading back to the Old House - for the last time - where FAUST was presented in a very different production from the one I had seen two years earlier.
Above: a scene from FAUST in the Barrault staging
The main attraction onstage was the Méphistophélès of the charismatic Bulgarian basso Nicolai Ghiaurov (above), who had made his Met debut three weeks earlier as Philip II in DON CARLO. Ghiaurov's splendid stage presence, aligned with his glamorous basso sound, was a thrill to experience.
Nicolai Ghiaurov - FAUST ~ Il etait temps
Four very fine American singers took the other leading roles in FAUST:
John Alexander (above, as Anatol in VANESSA)
Alexander was a real gentleman-tenor. There was no showing off or grand-standing, just performance after performance of top-level singing in a wide variety of roles. He sang with The Met in New York City and on tour, from 1961 to 1987, chalking up 380 appearances in everything from Mozart's IDOMENEO to Barber's VANESSA.
John Alexander - FAUST ~ aria - Met b'cast 1966
For all the excellence of his work at The Met, it was John Alexander's stunning performance as Bacchus in the New York City Opera's 1974 production of Strauss's ARIADNE AUF NAXOS that thrilled me the most; it was a performance that put this opera at the top of my "favorites" list, where it has stayed every since.
Jean Fenn (above) sang Marguerite with gleaming tone and well-projected high notes. Together with Alexander and Ghiaurov, she made the final trio the thrilling finish to the opera that it should be.
Although she never attained prima donna status, Ms. Fenn was engaging both to watch and to hear. At the New Met, I greatly enjoyed her Musetta, and she was my first-ever Eva in MEISTERSINGER. As of this writing, she is still with us.
There's few recorded tracks of Jean Fenn; I did locate this BOHEME duet with Mario Lanza:
Jean Fenn & Mario Lanza - O soave fanciulla ~ BOHEME
William Walker (Valentin) and Marcia Baldwin (Siebel) both had extensive careers at The Met, and in the ensuing years, I would encounter them many times onstage. In this FAUST - my final opera at the old Met - they were excellent.
William Walker (above) was a Met Auditions winner in 1962, and joined the Company immediately...and sang Papageno (in English) in his first Met season. Among his many roles were Kothner in MEISTERSINGER, the Herald in LOHENGRIN, both Schaunard and Marcello in BOHEME, Sharpless in BUTTERFLY, Enrico in LUCIA DI LAMMERMOOR, and Prince Yeletsky in QUEEN OF SPADES. He sang regularly at The Met until 1978.
William Walker - Valentin's aria ~ FAUST - Met bcast 1966
Marcia Baldwin (above) was the evening's Siebel, as she had been when I first saw this opera two years earlier. She sang the aria most attractively. Little could I have guessed that I would meet her and come to know her in a different context many years later, when I was living in New York City and working at Tower Records. When she passed away in 2016, one of my few remaining connections to the Old Met was lost.
Marcia Baldwin - Siebel's arias ~ FAUST - Met bcast 1966
As the opera drew to its close with that exciting trio, I wasn't really thinking "...this is the last time I will ever be here...", because I was hoping to get back for more Old Met performances in the Spring of 1966. It didn't happen. The next Met performance I saw was at Lincoln Center: Nilsson, Corelli, and Stratas in TURANDOT.
The life of an ardent opera-lover is full of ironies and coincidences: it hadn't dawned on me until recently that the last opera I saw at the Old Met was the Gounod masterpiece that had opened the House in 1883.
To end this reminiscence, here's the final trio of FAUST sung - as it was on that opening night in 1883 - in Italian. Of the three singers here, two (Pobbe and Poggi) had very limited Met careers, and the basso Raffaele Arie never sang there at all.
FAUST ~ final trio - in Italian - Marcella Pobbe - Gianni Poggi - Raffaele Arie
Above: final curtain call at the Old Met
~ Oberon
Note: the earlier installments of this story will be found here and here.