Above: mezzo-soprano Elīna Garanča
~ Author: Oberon
Friday June 14th, 2019 - This evening, The MET Orchestra paired Mahler's marvelous Rückert Lieder with Anton Bruckner's sprawling 7th symphony. Yannick Nézet-Séguin was on the podium, and the soloist for the Mahler was Elīna Garanča.
As Ms. Garanča, in a strikingly Spring-like white gown, and the conductor made their way center-stage, the mezzo towered over the maestro. M. Nézet-Séguin wore a clingy white shirt that seemed calculated to show off his physique; it looked kind of silly.
The German Romantic poet Friedrich Rückert (1788-1866) was one of Gustav Mahler’s favorite poets, and he set a number of his poems to music, including the Kindertotenlieder ("Songs on the Death of Children").
Mahler composed four of the five Rückert Lieder in 1901, initially to be sung with piano accompaniment; very soon after, he orchestrated them. The fifth of the Rückert Lieder, “Liebst du um Schönheit?” ('If you love for beauty...') was composed a bit later, and orchestrated by Mahler's publisher. The songs do not constitute a formal song-cycle, nor is there any prescribed order of performing them.
Ms. Garanča began with "Blicke mir nicht in die Lieder” ("Do not look at my songs..."), in which poet and composer seem to be warning the listener not to be too inquisitive about the song-writing process: it's the finished product that matters. This light and almost playful song was deliciously voiced by Ms. Garanča, whilst the woodwind players of The MET Orchestra buzzed charmingly about, like busy bees.
In "Ich atmet’ einen linden Duft" ("I breathed a gentle fragrance...") the mezzo-soprano brought an intriguing mix of calm and intensity. Her use of dynamics and her lovely sustaining of the vocal line were beautifully supported by the oboe, horn, and flute. The singer's lower range has a special warmth and glow: rich without seeming over-burdened.
A change of mood comes with "Um Mitternacht" ("At midnight") which tells of the poet’s battle with darkness (both in the literal and and the poetic sense) until he finally leaves it all in God's hands. Ms. Garanča brought profound beauty of tone to the song, giving it an almost operatic dimension. Her use of straight tone at times was beguiling, whilst throughout her expressive, passionate colouring of the words kept us engrossed. It seemed that the conductor allowed a passing trace of vulgarity in some of the wind playing, and he allowed the orchestra to cover the voice in the closing passages of the song.
"Liebst du um Schönheit" ("If you love for beauty...") was the first Mahler song I ever heard, sung at a 1972 recital by the delectable Frederica von Stade. A few years later, the unique voice of Patricia Brooks gave the song a different feeling. And it's a song I very much associate with my late friend, the Japanese contralto Makiko Narumi. The words, in translation, could have been the theme song of my long career as a promiscuous romantIc:
Following the interval, Maestro Nézet-Séguin returned for the Bruckner 7th. This was my first live experience of this work, which begins so magically with a string tremolo from which the glorious main theme arises. Throughout most of the first movement, I felt as engaged - and even exalted - as I had expected to feel, since I like Bruckner's music in general.
But in the ensuing Adagio, I found the performance drifting away from me. There were some iffy moments from the horns, the music seemed periodically to lose its shape, and the movement began to feel endless. The Scherzo which follows was singularly lacking in wit and sparkle, and while its tranquil - almost wistful - trio section is pleasant enough to hear, pleasant music tends to get boring after a while.
At last, the Finale is reached; I hoped that Bruckner would take the driver's seat and careen madly to the finish line. Instead, the music came in fits and starts, seeming to fold in on itself and retreat periodically into modestly attractive wind interludes. At last: a big statement. But this was soon replaced by more dawdling. Frankly, it couldn't end soon enough. I found myself craving Bizet's Symphony in C.
Afterwards, I asked myself why the Bruckner 7th had seemed like such a disappointment this evening. My friend Ben Weaver suggested that perhaps it was the performance, rather than the music, that had let me down. But it's something deeper.
In search of answers, I read some on-line articles by music-lovers who stated that Bruckner's music often eluded them. One common theme in many of these writings was Bruckner's seeming lack of a sex life: simplistic perhaps, but on the other hand we know that Mozart, Liszt, Wagner, Debussy, Puccini, and Mahler were men of passion, and it comes thru in their music. Bruckner's passion seems to have been for God, and some writers went so far as to say that Bruckner probably lived and died a virgin. This may account for a feeling of sterility in some of his music, and why it doesn't reach me. Oddly, reading about Bruckner and looking at some pictures of the man, I began thinking of Mike Pence.
Speaking of people's sex lives, in tonight's Playbill note about The MET Orchestra, the name of James Levine - the man universally credited with turning the opera house's orchestra into a world-class concert ensemble - is conspicuously absent. This gloss seems so childish, but I suppose in an age when slavery in America and the Holocaust in Europe are being written out of text books, anything is possible.
~ Oberon