~ Author: Oberon
Saturday November 24th, 2018 matinee - The New York City Opera used to perform Georges Bizet's Pêcheurs de Perles fairly often, and I saw it there four times in the 1980s with such sopranos as Diana Soviero, Carol Vaness, Diana Walker, and the enchanting Rachel Rosales; tenors Barry McCauley and Jerry Hadley; and baritones Dominic Cossa, William Stone, and Robert McFarland. During that time of my life, I really liked this melodious opera, with its enchanting soprano aria, a poetic (and difficult) tenor aria, and - of course - a beloved duet for tenor and baritone: "Au fond du temple saint".
But there's also a lot of filler, atmospheric in its way yet in the long run just...filler. Pêcheurs was not on my initial list of operas to see/hear at The Met this season; but as I was tallying up my score desk order, I added a couple of operas just to see if they'd still be of interest to me. Pêcheurs, as it turns out, isn't.
I had skipped this Met production of Pêcheurs when it was new, because I'd taken a strong dislike to Diana Damrau. This season, Pretty Yende is singing Leïla, a part which I imagined would suit her voice far better than Donizetti's Lucia had. "O Dieu Brahma!" is not the easiest way to start your afternoon. Ms. Yende's florid singing was not always fluent, and at times her pitch was a shade off; counter-balancing this were an ethereal high B-flat and a gorgeous high-D. I imagine her "Comme autrefois" would have been quite fine, but I couldn't outlast the intermission to find out.
Alexander Birch Elliott had stepped into the role of Zurga midway thru the season prima of Pêcheurs, replacing Mariusz Kwiecien, who has now withdrawn from the production due to illness. Mr. Elliott has a handsome lyric baritone voice, and he blended perfectly with Javier Camarena in their famous duet, which drew sustained applause.
Mr. Camarena's singing of the dreamy aria "Je crois entendre encore" was lovingly phrased, with exquisite piano effects. His voice is a bit light for this role in the big house, but it's wonderfully present and expressive.
On the podium, Emmanuel Villaume did what he could with this perfumed score, giving an atmospheric prelude (twice interrupted by applause); he sometimes let his orchestra cover the voices, however.
Hearing this opera again had the effect of finding a disintegrating, powdery rose pressed in the pages of a book you haven't opened in decades. You can't remember who gave you the flower or why it was significant enough to save, but you feel a twinge of regret that something that once meant something to you no longer does.
Metropolitan Opera House
November 124th, 2018 matinee
LES PÊCHEURS DE PERLES
Georges Bizet
Léila...................Pretty Yende
Nadir...................Javier Camarena
Zurga...................Alexander Birch Elliott
Nourabad................Nicolas Testé
Conductor...............Emmanuel Villaume
~ Oberon