Above: Edward Watson in the Royal Ballet's production of SONG OF THE EARTH; photo by Johan Persson
Thursday June 25th, 2015 - The Royal Ballet are presently at Lincoln Center, and this evening's double-bill of Sir Frederick Ashton's THE DREAM and Sir Kenneth MacMillan's SONG OF THE EARTH seemed particularly appealing to me, not least for the music of two of my favorite composers: Felix Mendelssohn and Gustav Mahler. The fact that Edward Watson would be appearing in the MacMillan made an appealing prospect irresistible.
Ashton's THE DREAM was the first ballet I ever saw live, performed by The Joffrey at New York's City Center on October 16th, 1974; Rebecca Wright, Burton Taylor, and Russell Sultzbach had the principal roles that evening. I've not seen the ballet again since that performance.
The Royal Ballet's production of the Ashton boasts a particularly evocative and gorgeous set, and lovely costumes - notably those for the corps of 'adult' fairies (unlike in Balanchine's version, there are no children to be seen in the Ashton, aside from the Changling Boy). Ashton tells the story in a more abbreviated rendering than Mr B - Ashton's mortal couples are less-fully-fleshed-out as characters than Balanchine's; Ashton's Titania has a more sensuous quality and his Puck is more annoying (in a good way) than their Balanchine counterparts. Ashton sometimes has Oberon and Puck doing virtuoso passages at the same time, and they oddly seem to cancel one another out.
The Mendelssohn score (played by the New York City Ballet orchestra - though in a different arrangement than that used for the Balanchine), sounded as charm-filled as ever, with some lovely singing from the Brooklyn Youth Chorus.
Above: Matthew Golding as Oberon in THE DREAM; photo by Bill Cooper
Matthew Golding's tall, long-limbed Oberon, with beautifully up-right pirouettes, was handsomely characterized with a mixture of nobility and sexiness. Natalia Osipova was a lushly sensuous Titania, with an interesting touch of earthiness. Dancing in oddly-battered toe shoes, she had just polished off a lovely solo passage when suddenly she slipped and fell to the floor; she re-bounded at once and went on to a winning performance, beautifully meshed with Mr. Golding in their pas de deux.
Valentino Zucchetti was a sprightly Puck; his performance was a big hit with the audience and though I prefer the Balanchine portrait of this character, Zucchetti's dancing had plenty of verve. Jonathan Howells met the challenge of dancing Bottom on pointe. The mortal couples were finely danced, making the most of their fleeting vignettes: a special bravo to Ryoichi Hirano for his excellent Lysander. A pretty quartet of principal fairies, given their Shakespearean names, added yet another delectable element to the performance.
Above: Edward Watson, Laura Morera, and Nehemiah Kish in SONG OF THE EARTH; photo from The Royal Ballet's website
I had no idea what to expect from Kenneth MacMillan's SONG OF THE EARTH. In pondering what it might be like, my first thought was that Mahler's score is singularly unsuited to dance. But how wrong I was! I ended up being thoroughly mesmerized by the unexpected 'rightness' of MacMillan's setting of the music, and by the superb dancing of the three principals.
If there's a more distinctive danseur on the planet than Edward Watson (above), I've yet to find him. The lithe muscularity, the pale skin, the ginger hair, and the hypnotic eyes - clearly gleaming thru a half-masque tonight as MacMillan's Messenger of Death - combined with a lyrically powerful technique make his performances (far too rare here in Gotham) something to cherish. The moment I saw his name listed for this evening's performance I knew I had to be there.
A great pleasure to see Nehemiah Kish (above) again; he danced with MORPHOSES in their premiere New York season. Tall and with an easy command of space, his role in the MacMillan serves as both a compliment and a counter-poise to Edward Watson's character: at the very end of the ballet, Mr. Kish appears masked, clearly 'marked' by Mr. Watson's influence.
New to me and making a magnificent impression was Laura Morera, a Spanish-born ballerina whose clarity of steps and of gesture as well as a radiant, far-searching gaze, marked her as a unique presence: despite the overwhelming allure of Mssers. Watson and Kish, I found it hard to take my eyes off Ms. Morera. She showed a deep connection to the music, and a blessed freedom from theatricality. (The rehearsal photo of Laura Morera above is from The Royal Ballet website...I simply love it...and her!)
The Mahler score of Das Lied von der Erde calls for two vocal soloists: they alternate in singing the songs. For his ballet, MacMillan has them unobtrusively step out from the opposite sides of the proscenium to sing; thus the focus remains on the dancers throughout. Tenor Thomas Randle seemed a bit stressed by the vocal demands cruelly placed on him by Mahler, but he managed well enough. Katherine Goeldner, who a few seasons back was an excellent Carmen on this very stage, summoned up some very expressive vocalism, making an especially haunting effect in the final passages of the work as she repeats the word "Ewig..." ('Forever') in gradations from piano to lingering pianissimo.
To attempt to describe for New York dance-goers the overall look of the choreography MacMillan devised for this musically epic piece one might say it combines the stripped-down immediacy of Balanchine's black-and-white ballets with the ritualistic aspects of Martha Graham's mythic masterworks.
In the abstract yet curiously meaningful passages for the corps, MacMillan has created a stylized world thru which the principals and soloists come and go with alternating sensations of urgency and angular introspection. Irony manifests itself at times, but overall the work takes itself very seriously and that in itself makes it all the more compelling.
There were times when I wished for a bit more sense of unity of movement from the ensemble; of course Mahler's endless thematic ebbs and flows don't provide a real rhythmic blueprint for synchronization of steps and gestures. Nevertheless, everyone looked wonderfully handsome and attractive, individual personalities emerging even in the regimented sequences.
To the splendid performances from Ms. Morera, Mr. Watson, and Mr. Kish were added some radiant dancing from Yuhui Choe and Lara Turk. There were others, too, who caught the questing gaze of my opera glasses but I'm not familiar enough with the Company to single them out.
In a week that brought the news of Albert Evans' untimely death, it was moving to be back in the theatre where I saw him dance hundreds of times. So lovely, too, to run into Wendy Whelan, who shared that stage with Albert on countless evenings. My feeling is that Albert would not want us to stop dancing...not even for a moment.